← All writing
Newsletter · 3 min read ·

When people ask what I do these days, I say I’m a writer and coach.

And in the quiet between my own ears, the questions start up, and they don’t take turns.

When people ask what I do these days, I say I’m a writer and coach. I can’t bring myself to say “parenting influencer.” Writer is the more honest title anyway, because most of my hours go to reading, writing, re-reading, researching and rewriting, and almost all of it happens alone.

And in the quiet between my own ears, the questions start up, and they don’t take turns.

Is that good enough? Are you good enough? Are you doing life right? What if people think you’re a fraud? Aren’t you tired of your own face? Fix your hair. Are you actually a good dad? A good husband?

I’m not unique. We all walk around with self-doubt; people leave trails of it in my comments every day. I’m much quicker to tell them to be kind to themselves than I am to tell myself.

But I’ve noticed there are moments when it disappears.

When I walk up to school pickup, or log in to Zoom for a class, and I’m looking into the faces of other people, the questions go quiet. It isn’t because I’ve hacked my way into some inner bliss. I’m just present and useful to the people in front of me, and there’s no room left for the questions.

For a long time I thought that meant something was off about me: that I was a people pleaser, externally dependent, the weak link. I believed other people had access to the real thing, a quiet, unshakable belief that lived on the inside. Mine was borrowed.

I don’t think that anymore, because there’s a word for what I feel in those moments: mattering.

Researchers have been studying it since 1981, when sociologist Morris Rosenberg started asking adolescents a simple question: do you feel like you matter to the people around you? The psychologist Isaac Prilleltensky later described mattering as two halves that have to work together, feeling valued and adding value.

With our kids, we’re pretty good at the first half. We tell them we love them, that they’re special, that we’re proud. The second half is the one we overlook.

Jennifer Breheny Wallace has done more than anyone lately to bring mattering into the parenting conversation. She interviewed kids for her book Never Enough. Some of the ones struggling most had heard plenty from their parents about being valued, but they had never been depended on to add value to anyone but themselves. Reassurance without evidence feels hollow, like a table missing a leg.

That was the piece I’d been missing. Confidence isn’t something you build alone in your room and then carry out into the world. It shows up when you have proof that you have a positive effect on the people around you. Someone smiles because of something you said. A sibling says thanks. A team actually needed you to show up. Real confidence doesn’t come from an idea about yourself. It comes from the agency you feel when you’ve made something better for someone else.

Every middle schooler is questioning who they are, every single day. We’re quick to reassure them, but what they want more than anything is evidence that they have influence.

We want our kids to believe in themselves. But we’ve told them to look for that belief in the one place it’s hardest to find: alone, inside themselves. The evidence they’re looking for is more likely to show up in someone else’s gratitude, someone’s smile, someone’s laugh.

That’s the confidence that lasts.

This week, give your kid one real job. Make it something the household actually depends on, not a chore you invented to build character. They could make dinner on Thursday, walk their little brother to the bus, or be the one who calls Grandma on Sunday. When it’s done, skip “good job.” Tell them exactly what it did for someone else: “Your brother made it on time because of you.” “Grandma talked about your call all night.”

That isn’t praise. It’s evidence, and evidence is what confidence is built from.

Get the next letter on Saturday.

One classroom-tested practice in your inbox, every week. Free, plainspoken, unsubscribe in one click.